For Caatinga’s final jaguars and pumas, wind farms are the latest risk


Between March 2017 and January 2018, researchers tracked the actions of a feminine puma because it prowled across the Boqueirão da Onça protected space complicated within the north of Brazil’s Bahia state.

They’d named her Vitória, the primary puma (Puma concolor) within the area to be captured and fitted with a radio collar, which researchers from the Amigos da Onça program, a wildcat undertaking affiliated with conservation nonprofit Pró-Carnívoros, used to map her actions.

Throughout this explicit interval, they observed a change in Vitória’s roaming.

In part of her vary, a wind farm was being constructed, an exercise related to a lot of noise, clearing of vegetation for roads, a continuing human presence, and a excessive frequency of auto visitors.

Shortly, the puma started to keep away from the work space and its environment.

“In these 10 months, she didn’t cross the realm of wind generators,” says Carolina Esteves, a researcher at Pró-Carnívoros and co-founder of Amigos da Onça.

“And this higher motion of the puma, circling your complete complicated to succeed in a water level, implies an even bigger vitality value.”

Researchers additionally noticed the identical behavioral change, of sustaining distance from the development website, among the many area’s jaguars (Panthera onca).

Typical open Caatinga landscape in the Boqueirão da Onça region. Image courtesy of Carolina F. Esteves.
Typical open Caatinga panorama within the Boqueirão da Onça area. Picture courtesy of Carolina F. Esteves.

Pumas and jaguars happen throughout a variety of Brazil’s biomes, with every inhabitants differing to a sure diploma primarily based on their habitat, Esteves says. Right here within the Caatinga, in Brazil’s northeast, the cats, each dun and dappled, are smaller, have stiffer whiskers and thicker leg hair to take care of the warmer open floor than their cousins in, say, the plush forests of the Amazon or the wetlands of the Pantanal. To outlive on this biome, having the ability to discover water can also be essential.

“We often say that if we catch an grownup [puma or jaguar] from another biome and launch it within the Caatinga, it most likely received’t survive, particularly throughout the dry season,” Esteves says. “When a cub is born, for a 12 months and a half to 2 years the mom will educate him every part he must know to outlive. Within the Caatinga, along with the best way to hunt and shield itself, it is going to additionally present you the place the primary water factors are.”

The issue with the affect of wind farms, which jars with their repute for producing clear electrical energy, is that the Caatinga massive cats are on the verge of extinction, they usually depend upon the native forests to outlive.

It’s estimated there are solely 250 jaguars and a couple of,500 pumas left in your complete biome. Of this complete, 30 jaguars are present in Boqueirão da Onça. The complicated is made up of a nationwide park, which is strictly protected, and a bigger environmental safety space (APA), the place a point of sustainable human exercise is permitted. Collectively, the park and the APA cowl 853,000 hectares (2.11 million acres), accounting for the most important protected space complicated within the Caatinga.

A camera-trap image of a jaguar with a radio collar in the Boqueirão da Onça region. Image courtesy of Amigos da Onça.
A camera-trap picture of a jaguar with a radio collar within the Boqueirão da Onça area. Picture courtesy of Amigos da Onça.

The jaguar is listed as critically endangered within the Caatinga, one stage shy of being declared regionally extinct from the wild right here. The puma fares higher, however its classification as endangered within the Caatinga is worse than in all the opposite biomes in Brazil, the place the species is assessed as susceptible.

Compounding the issue, the inhabitants estimates that Esteves and her group are working with could also be overly optimistic, as they arrive from a 2013 survey. “From the experiences we’ve of looking and confirmed elimination of people, the present estimates should not good,” she says.

Progress of wind farms within the Caatinga

If Vitória was already exhibiting adjustments in her actions six years in the past, it’s straightforward to think about that the massive cats in the identical area face a way more troublesome actuality at present, researchers say.

There are at present 4 wind farms working within the Boqueirão da Onça APA, one in every of them with 500 towers. “And there are six extra wind farms to be put in,” says Cláudia Bueno de Campos, a carnivore biologist and co-founder of Amigos da Onça, who can also be an official with the Brazilian Ministry of Surroundings’s Chico Mendes Institute for Biodiversity Conservation (ICMBio).

A wind farm in the Caatinga biome. Image courtesy of Ismael A. Silva.
A wind farm within the Caatinga biome. Picture courtesy of Ismael A. Silva.

Along with wind farms, the area has additionally grow to be enticing for photo voltaic vitality technology. In 2021, the primary photo voltaic plant was constructed right here, clearing 3,000 hectares (7,400 acres) of native Caatinga vegetation within the course of.

“The elimination of vegetation on the tops of the mountains alters the pure movement of rainwater that feeds the environment, and this impacts close by springs, which may dry up,” Campos says. “These springs are extraordinarily necessary for the massive cats, as a result of throughout droughts they grow to be the one water factors for them to drink, to not point out their significance for the native individuals.”

Conflicts with farmers

For many years, conservationists had pushed for the creation of a giant protected space within the Boqueirão da Onça area as a means of making certain the conservation of the wildlife on this comparatively well-preserved a part of the Caatinga.

Lastly, in 2018, then-president Michel Temer signed a decree reworking an space of 347,557 hectares (858,832 acres) into Boqueirão da Onça Nationwide Park, and, adjoining to it, 505,692 hectares (1.25 million acres) for Boqueirão da Onça Environmental Safety Space.

The choice to not set up your complete space as a nationwide park left environmentalists pissed off. However vitality corporations welcomed the transfer, because the area demonstrated huge potential for his or her enterprise.

Boqueirão da Onça Environmental Protection Area, in green, and the smaller Boqueirão da Onça National Park, in light green. Image courtesy of Amigos da Onça.
Boqueirão da Onça Environmental Safety Space, in inexperienced, and the smaller Boqueirão da Onça Nationwide Park, in mild inexperienced. Picture courtesy of Amigos da Onça.

Brazil’s northeast area is residence to 90% of the nation’s wind farms, 85% of them within the Caatinga, largely within the states of Rio Grande do Norte and Bahia. State and municipal governments have welcomed the investments that these tasks have ushered in, however for conservationists they’ve exacerbated an age-old downside: the deliberate killing of huge cats.

“When confronted with wind farms and having to maneuver a lot farther to search out sources resembling water and meals, massive cats usually find yourself getting nearer to rural properties the place there are home animals and even herds of goats, one thing widespread on this area,” says Paulo Marinho, an ecologist on the Federal College of Rio Grande do Norte and specialist in Caatinga mammal conservation. “This intensifies conflicts between farmers and these cats, leading to deaths.”

Goats in the Caatinga. Image courtesy of Carolina F. Esteves.
Goats within the Caatinga. Picture courtesy of Carolina F. Esteves.

To forestall the financial losses from the predation of their livestock, farmers set traps that find yourself killing pumas and jaguars.

That’s why, along with learning and monitoring the cats’ populations, Amigos da Onça runs an “schooling for conservation” program for native communities and livestock ranchers to get them to co-exist extra peacefully with the predators. This features a particular undertaking to forestall retaliatory killings by the ranchers, however the final goal is to search out methods to make sure the cats don’t assault home animals and livestock within the first place.

To that finish, the researchers have helped develop particular pens that the massive cats can’t get into, in contrast to the normal corrals which might be utterly open. At evening, goats and sheep are herded into these pens, which, as an additional benefit, are effectively ventilated and heat, leading to higher well being and high quality of the meat for future sale.

An Amigos da Onça researcher, left, and a rancher inspect a livestock pen designed to keep big cats out. Image courtesy of Anderson Gomes.
An Amigos da Onça researcher, left, and a rancher examine a livestock pen designed to maintain massive cats out. Picture courtesy of Anderson Gomes.

The ugly duckling of Brazilian biomes

Till the start of this century, there have been barely any research on the massive cats of the Caatinga, though there was little doubt that they’d at all times existed on this semiarid area: rock work, some relationship again 25,000 years, depict jaguars among the many wildlife native to the area. The sheer abundance of biodiversity within the Amazon, to the east, and the Atlantic Forest, to the south, has lengthy overshadowed the Caatinga, leaving it little studied as a consequence. It was even believed that the aridity of the soil indicated a shortage of wildlife, which couldn’t be farther from the reality.

The primary warnings in regards to the worrying scenario of huge cats within the biome got here from a survey carried out between 2006 and 2011 by ICMBio’s Nationwide Middle for Analysis and Conservation of Carnivorous Mammals (CENAP). The primary focus was on jaguars, however it was observed that pumas have been additionally beneath risk; and with out defending one, the opposite wouldn’t survive.

“It was attainable to see the fragility of the species,” says Campos. who participated within the analysis.

Following the survey, she noticed an pressing have to take motion to guard the felines. Thus Amigos da Onça, or Mates of the Massive Cats, was born in 2012.

A camera-trap image of Vitória, the first puma to be tagged for monitoring in the Boqueirão da Onça region. Image courtesy of Amigos da Onça.
A camera-trap picture of Vitória, the primary puma to be tagged for monitoring within the Boqueirão da Onça area. Picture courtesy of Amigos da Onça.

But regardless of the efforts revamped the previous decade by the researchers and their collaborators within the discipline, all working voluntarily for the conservation of those animals, the fact that’s unfolded has been a dismal one.

“The opening of roads for these wind farms, for instance, facilitates entry for hunters,” Esteves says. “Many take a look at wind generators are put in with out prior permission from the licensing physique. Corporations open entry roads and place towers with measuring units for about one 12 months. At this level, the harm has already been accomplished.

“Reviews from residents are heartbreaking,” she provides. “With every dialog, extra roads are opened, vegetation is eliminated.”

Esteves says one of many aggravating components continues to be the best way wherein the Caatinga is perceived in relation to different Brazilian biomes.

“The large problem is to convey the eye of the inhabitants, public insurance policies and the media to the biome. The Caatinga is seen because the ugly duckling of biomes. That is mirrored within the lack of sources for its enchancment,” Esteves says. “Look how lengthy it took us to know the worth that the biome has. The Caatinga continues to be not thought of a nationwide heritage by the Structure. That should change.”

At the same time as that notion persists, the march of renewable vitality growth is relentless. With each passing second, conservationists warn, the few remaining pumas and jaguars that also survive within the Caatinga develop ever extra threatened.

“You will need to make it clear that the facility technology proposal is extraordinarily related and necessary,” Esteves says, “however what wants to maneuver ahead on the identical pace is the understanding of the affect of those tasks in conserved areas.”

What you are able to do

Help ‘Combating for Wildlife’ by donating as little as $1 – It solely takes a minute. Thanks.


Combating for Wildlife helps permitted wildlife conservation organizations, which spend at the very least 80 % of the cash they elevate on precise fieldwork, fairly than administration and fundraising. When making a donation you’ll be able to designate for which sort of initiative it ought to be used – wildlife, oceans, forests or local weather.

 This article by Suzana Camargo was first printed by Mongabay.comon 22 August 2023 | Translated by Caio Saad. Lead Picture: Puma in Boqueirão da Onça Environmental Safety Space, Bahia state, Brazil. Picture courtesy of Roland Brack/ Amigos da Onça.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here